cover

Chart Detective

How can graphs and charts mislead us if we are not careful?
A good chart is an **honest friend**. It takes a pile of confusing numbers and turns them into a shape your eyes can gra

A good chart is an honest friend. It takes a pile of confusing numbers and turns them into a shape your eyes can grasp in a second. But here's the twist: the very same chart can be dressed up to fool you โ€” without telling a single lie. Same numbers, sneaky outfit. Let's catch a few in the act.

++Trick number one++: the cut-off bottom. Most bar charts start counting at zero. But **snip that bottom off**, and a ti

Trick number one: the cut-off bottom. Most bar charts start counting at zero. But snip that bottom off, and a tiny difference suddenly looks enormous. Imagine two towers that are really 99 and 100 floors tall โ€” almost the same. Chop the picture so it only shows floors 98 to 100, and now one tower looks like it towers over the other. The numbers didn't change. The starting line did.

~~Trick number two:~~ the squished and stretched axis. A line going up can look like **a gentle hill or a terrifying cli

Trick number two: the squished and stretched axis. A line going up can look like a gentle hill or a terrifying cliff, depending on how tall or wide you draw it. Squeeze the sides together and a calm trend becomes a rocket. Stretch them apart and a real jump becomes a sleepy flatline. The clever reader always peeks at the side numbers before gasping.

++Trick number three++: **cherry-picking the window**. Pick only the months that suit your story and hide the rest. A pr

Trick number three: cherry-picking the window. Pick only the months that suit your story and hide the rest. A price might be falling all year โ€” but show just the one week it rose, and suddenly everything looks like it's booming. It's like cropping a photo to leave out the puddle you fell in.

++Trick number four++: the balloon problem. Sometimes charts use pictures โ€” bigger blob means bigger number. But if you

Trick number four: the balloon problem. Sometimes charts use pictures โ€” bigger blob means bigger number. But if you double a circle's width, its area doesn't double, it balloons to four times the size. So a number that's only a little bigger can look gigantically bigger. Your eyes judge the whole blob, not the width.

~~Trick number five:~~ missing labels. A bar can be **any height it wants** if nobody says what it's measuring. *Dollars

Trick number five: missing labels. A bar can be any height it wants if nobody says what it's measuring. Dollars? People? Slices of cake? Without a clear label and units, a chart is just pretty shapes making a confident face. A chart with no labels is a stranger insisting "trust me."

++Trick number six++: **the pie that's too full**. A pie chart shows parts of one whole, so all the slices must *add up

Trick number six: the pie that's too full. A pie chart shows parts of one whole, so all the slices must add up to 100 percent. But sneaky pies sometimes overlap or count things twice, so the slices add up to more than a whole pie. If the pieces don't add up, something's been double-served.

~~Here's the secret~~ all these tricks share: they don't change the data โ€” _they change the costume_. The chart still te

Here's the secret all these tricks share: they don't change the data โ€” they change the costume. The chart still tells the truth in its numbers; it's the drawing that whispers a fib. Which means you have a superpower. Look at the bottom line. Check the side numbers. Read the labels. Ask what's left out.

~~So charts aren't villains~~ โ€” they're just powerful, and **powerful things deserve a second glance**. A good one shows

So charts aren't villains โ€” they're just powerful, and powerful things deserve a second glance. A good one shows you the world more clearly than words ever could. A sneaky one just hopes you won't look twice. Now you always will. And that little pause before you gasp? That's the most honest thing on the whole page.

How was this book?

A Wonderleaf Book

Chart Detective

โ€” How can graphs and charts mislead us if we are not careful? โ€”

Wonderleaf Editions
โ€” ex libris โ€”
A Wonderleaf Book

Chart Detective

How can graphs and charts mislead us if we are not careful?

Wonderleaf Editions ยท MMXXVI
Scene 1
A good chart is an **honest friend**. It takes a pile of confusing numbers and turns them into a shape your eyes can gra
Chart Detective2
Scene 1

A good chart is an honest friend. It takes a pile of confusing numbers and turns them into a shape your eyes can grasp in a second. But here's the twist: the very same chart can be dressed up to fool you โ€” without telling a single lie. Same numbers, sneaky outfit. Let's catch a few in the act.

3Chart Detective
Scene 2
++Trick number one++: the cut-off bottom. Most bar charts start counting at zero. But **snip that bottom off**, and a ti
Chart Detective4
Scene 2

Trick number one: the cut-off bottom. Most bar charts start counting at zero. But snip that bottom off, and a tiny difference suddenly looks enormous. Imagine two towers that are really 99 and 100 floors tall โ€” almost the same. Chop the picture so it only shows floors 98 to 100, and now one tower looks like it towers over the other. The numbers didn't change. The starting line did.

5Chart Detective
Scene 3
~~Trick number two:~~ the squished and stretched axis. A line going up can look like **a gentle hill or a terrifying cli
Chart Detective6
Scene 3

Trick number two: the squished and stretched axis. A line going up can look like a gentle hill or a terrifying cliff, depending on how tall or wide you draw it. Squeeze the sides together and a calm trend becomes a rocket. Stretch them apart and a real jump becomes a sleepy flatline. The clever reader always peeks at the side numbers before gasping.

7Chart Detective
Scene 4
++Trick number three++: **cherry-picking the window**. Pick only the months that suit your story and hide the rest. A pr
Chart Detective8
Scene 4

Trick number three: cherry-picking the window. Pick only the months that suit your story and hide the rest. A price might be falling all year โ€” but show just the one week it rose, and suddenly everything looks like it's booming. It's like cropping a photo to leave out the puddle you fell in.

9Chart Detective
Scene 5
++Trick number four++: the balloon problem. Sometimes charts use pictures โ€” bigger blob means bigger number. But if you
Chart Detective10
Scene 5

Trick number four: the balloon problem. Sometimes charts use pictures โ€” bigger blob means bigger number. But if you double a circle's width, its area doesn't double, it balloons to four times the size. So a number that's only a little bigger can look gigantically bigger. Your eyes judge the whole blob, not the width.

11Chart Detective
Scene 6
~~Trick number five:~~ missing labels. A bar can be **any height it wants** if nobody says what it's measuring. *Dollars
Chart Detective12
Scene 6

Trick number five: missing labels. A bar can be any height it wants if nobody says what it's measuring. Dollars? People? Slices of cake? Without a clear label and units, a chart is just pretty shapes making a confident face. A chart with no labels is a stranger insisting "trust me."

13Chart Detective
Scene 7
++Trick number six++: **the pie that's too full**. A pie chart shows parts of one whole, so all the slices must *add up
Chart Detective14
Scene 7

Trick number six: the pie that's too full. A pie chart shows parts of one whole, so all the slices must add up to 100 percent. But sneaky pies sometimes overlap or count things twice, so the slices add up to more than a whole pie. If the pieces don't add up, something's been double-served.

15Chart Detective
Scene 8
~~Here's the secret~~ all these tricks share: they don't change the data โ€” _they change the costume_. The chart still te
Chart Detective16
Scene 8

Here's the secret all these tricks share: they don't change the data โ€” they change the costume. The chart still tells the truth in its numbers; it's the drawing that whispers a fib. Which means you have a superpower. Look at the bottom line. Check the side numbers. Read the labels. Ask what's left out.

17Chart Detective
Scene 9
~~So charts aren't villains~~ โ€” they're just powerful, and **powerful things deserve a second glance**. A good one shows
Chart Detective18
Scene 9

So charts aren't villains โ€” they're just powerful, and powerful things deserve a second glance. A good one shows you the world more clearly than words ever could. A sneaky one just hopes you won't look twice. Now you always will. And that little pause before you gasp? That's the most honest thing on the whole page.

19Chart Detective

~ finis ~

Tiny picture books for big little questions.

โ€” a small constellation of questions โ€”
โœฆWonderleaf
Editions